New York Pizza Bar and Grill in Seattle

500 Mercer St, Seattle, WA 98109-4654, Seattle

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Pizza
  • Vegetarian Friendly
  • Gluten Free Options
Features
  • Television
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Full Bar
  • Takeout
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Reservations
Good for
  • Bar scene
  • Families witd children
  • Kids
  • Large groups

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Review

Add rating restaurant:
New York Pizza Bar and Grill
TT
Tanner Trisoliere
google
04.18.2024
1/5

This place needs to be on bar rescue.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
SP
Sharon Philipp
google
11.18.2018
5/5

Friendly people, good service, great pizza, and karaoke. 🍕🎤 We had so much fun !!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
RL
Rich Latimer
google
10.26.2018
1/5

First time, Last time. Flavorless as cardboard. No point saying more.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
SM
Sherry Martineau Kane
google
10.22.2018
5/5

What can I say..Nothing but the best is there to say. From a restaurant, to a local bar, to an small event facility. They have it all. Great people, delicious food, a variety of events and specials always going on. Then owner and the ladies who serve you, give you a truly five star experience.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
DB
Darrell Bragdon
google
10.16.2018
4/5

Good food at decent prices. Exceeded expectations.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
PM
Peggy Manor
google
10.12.2018
2/5

The food was awful. Atmosphere, terrible. Restrooms beyond filthy and everything took forever.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
SD
Susan Davey
google
09.08.2018
5/5

I really enjoy the menu. The onion rings are perfect. The service from the singing bartender is so well attentive, he doesn't come and ask how you're doing when your mouth is filled, he asks when you can answer. Tell him to make you a mystery drink and you will be satisfied.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
Gt
George the Viking
google
08.22.2018
1/5

Ordered online through their website. Didn't have to wait too much longer than the estimated time for the order. Went to pay cash and they decided they needed to charge me more than what it said on their website. The pizza was average, not bad and not great. Won't be back if they have to yank people around for a dollar though.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
RT
Rebecca Talley
google
08.17.2018
5/5

The food was fantastic!! I'm from Chicago and we know good Italian/American food. This place has it in spades! We had a Groupon and ordered stromboli, "The Works" Calzone, a white pizza, eggplant parmesan, and cheddar poppers. Everything was amazing.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
CB
Candiann Brown
google
08.15.2018
5/5

Love it, very clean place,such a sweet lady that works in daytime on weekends .. drinks are good , the food is okay ..

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
AN
Andrew Natonabah
google
08.09.2018
5/5

Great place to have a beer. Staff is friendly and good on service. Only one pool table though and is usually open. Amazing atmosphere and music.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
AN
Ashlee Navarro
google
07.26.2018
4/5

Always a great place to go see the fights. Service is a little slow and seems like they are never quite prepared for the amount of people that show up on fight night, BUT they are attentive and the food is delicious! Has a homey, very friendly sort of atmosphere and food has always been delicious.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
Vg
Victoria gaviria
google
07.11.2018
1/5

This place needs bar rescue I just walked out of there I arrived by myself, wasn't greeted or seated okay no problem, I waited 30 minutes expecting someone to approach me they weren't busy had 2 tables when I arrived, after 30 minutes I approached the bar to ask for my drink then went back to my seat hoping someone would give me a menu or take my food order. The employees were checking on other people, some more people arrived and they had no problem going up to them and checking on them taking their orders. I'm speachless,I have been in this business for 7 years I would NEVER blatantly ignore a customer, I'm not sure why I was never acknowledged but it's the servers loss because I'm a GREAT tipper I was there for an HR& a half part of me was gnna sit there longer just to see if they would ever check on me

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
mf
mike fissel
google
06.23.2018
4/5

Pizza great wings great too but very small like pidgeon wings. Comw here once a month.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
TR
Teresa Ross
google
06.16.2018
5/5

Wings and pizza were good! Lots of tv's for watching sports. Waitress was busy but still very pleasant. Good spot!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
CC
Cindy Cruz
google
05.08.2018
5/5

Best wings! Beats Native any day! Gold spicy flavor recommended. Definitely my new place to go for wings.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MK
Melissa Kagan
google
05.06.2018
5/5

The service was superb: bartender moy excelente!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MV
Michael Vigorito
google
04.17.2018
5/5

I have never had a bad meal at Maya's. I am an Italian from Brooklyn so I am hard to please in the food department, but Maya's has become my savior....

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
SC
Stevie Castro
google
04.01.2018
1/5

Me and my girlfriend are old employees here. We came in July 8th around 3:45pm. The food was good Gonzalo is a great cook. Our first server they call her cricket. Was good she kept taking sure we were ok like a server/bartender should. Well her shift came to an end, me n my gf wanted to drink more. Letty came in, not once did she come j check on is or ask us if we wanted more drinks we sat there for 30-45 min waiting for her to serve us. Whatever way she feels about us shoulda been put behind her. We haven't worked there since October or November Letty needs to grow up and let by gones be by gones!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
DM
David Moore
google
01.24.2018
1/5

Ordered a cheese pizza. The most simple thing to make. PLEASE DO NOT CALL THIS NEW YORK PIZZA. I would say it was like they went to little Cesar's and grabbed a $5 pizza but that would be an improvement. I've eaten gas station pizza with more flavor. The sauce tasted like they bought a 20¢ can of tomato paste and thought that was good enough.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
Wk
Wes klassik
google
01.13.2018
5/5

This place hands down has the best burger and salmon I will never go anywhere else for these things lol. The vibe is great for all ages, if I could give e it. More then 5 stars I definitely would..

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
JW
James Waide
google
11.02.2017
5/5

Great Italian food and great service. We've had some great pizza and also attended UFC events. I think it is the best pizza in Mesa.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MG
Michael Gelina
google
10.16.2017
1/5

This is simply the worst pizza and service we have ever had from a "pizza joint". Forget about even ordering from this place. You have other options to choose from and thousands of times better. They screwed up our order, never delivered a promised correct order and then told us we were wrong 2 1/2 hours after deliver was to occur. They should go out of business. THUMBS DOWN!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
LB
Leanna Butler
google
10.03.2017
5/5

This place Rocks. They have great service. And I had the best Pizza in my entire life here. I will definitely be back on a regular basis.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
DD
Dolores Damian
google
09.08.2017
5/5

We were super hungry so everything was good. We got medium wings, they were abit cold. Wished they were warmer. I also got the supreme pizza without mushrooms. It was good. Reminded me of peter piper pizza but better. My brother got the Italian sub toasted with a side salad. The side salad comes with olives & mushrooms as well. They were nice about using the Groupon. Make sure you get 4 meals or 4 people if you do buy it though. There’s a pool table by the bar.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
AJ
Abby Juarez-Moncada
google
09.02.2017
1/5

Had a rough day and thought pizza would be the cure. I was wrong. Service was terribly slow for a Monday evening, order took at least 30 minutes for one pizza. The pizza tasted like it was a reheated, jarred sauce mess. Don't waste your time or money here. However, if you're looking for a bar to go this might be the place. Staff took more time with the bar patrons than with the dining room.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
SJ
Sue Jones
google
07.07.2017
1/5

To be honest their food is not that good and the prices are way to high. The customer service needs an overhaul as well. Every single time I call in to place an order we cant hear each other because they are absolutely blasting the music in the background. The owner should do an undercover boss on his own place and fix some things.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
DW
Dan W
google
07.07.2017
3/5

Unfortunately I couldn't get something to eat (thus a middle star rating). I phoned in and was asked to wait, during the time I hear young adults cracking jokes while loud music in the background. After over 5 minutes of waiting and listening to the noise I had to take my business elsewhere. I'll try again another time.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
VW
Veronda Webster
google
06.20.2017
5/5

I've been here a few times now. It's a very nice place to go relax and have a drink. Their pizza is very good also. The wait staff is very attentive. The place is clean. They also have karaoke a couple times a week. It's never very busy and I don't know why. It should be. , It's a great place. I'll visit this place regularly.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
CM
C M
google
06.13.2017
1/5

WORST ESTABLISHMENT!!! If I could leave 0 stars I would! Service is terrible, food is terrible, drinks extremely overpriced and not even a consistent price for the exact same drinks! The restrooms are disgusting! Watched employees doing drugs in the hall or in the bathroom and drinking on the job not even caring they are seen by customers. Owner Moos (Mo) is extremely rude! BEWARE if you use a debit or credit card, they will add an extra tip for themselves! Filed a fraud claim with my bank as I do keep my receipts out of habit when visiting any restaurant. After telling a friend, I was informed it happened to them on 2 occasions. This place needs to be investigated and shut down! Never going back and DO NOT recommend this sorry place.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
BB
Blue Brazelton
google
06.13.2017
5/5

Great staff here. The food is good but the people are the best part.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
AG
Andrew Gibbons
google
05.18.2017
5/5

Was out of this world had 2 med pizzas. Fead 4 of us with left overs. Will be back.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
lm
lina maria
google
04.18.2017
5/5

It's good.... Mustafa owns the place.... Good service... And delicious food

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
GB
Grace Bailey
google
03.26.2017
1/5

If you'd like to know what a hot lunchable pizza tastes like , then this is the place.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
KC
Kendra Cota
google
01.21.2017
3/5

Good wings but the guy at the bar was a little rude!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
CG
Cynthia Guillen
google
11.27.2016
1/5

They had no social distancing enforcement. Some workers weren't wearing masks. I spent almost $40 and I couldn't even eat my food due to the horrible sticky tables that were obviously not cleaned often. If you just want drinks, go for it. If you want food, zero recommendations, if that's how they keep what I could see, I don't want to imagine their kitchen.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MS
Michael Soto
google
11.18.2016
4/5

It's a pretty good place, the owner is very involved in his business.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
WR
Wendy Reynolds
google
11.04.2016
1/5

The only reason I'm giving them a 1 🌟 is to report the issue we had with this company. They took our order at 8:30 pm and mentioned it would be 45 min. We live about 6 min away from the restaurant. We ordered a calzone, antipasto salad and 10 boneless chicken wings... (If thats what they call them: I'd say ground up chicken balls??? 😩🙄) We waited about an hour and had to call them about our order. The lady was rude without asking who we were she said it's on the way, and hung up! 25 min later we were in the phone again, asking for a refund. No such luck telling us it's on its way! A bunch of BS! 25 min later we got in the phone again and talked with a so called manager RUDE and said they were extremely busy and the driver had too many delivery's and couldn't take our order, so it will be coming. No REDUNDS. WE received our order at 10:14pm PATHETIC

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
tm
tj mikhailov
google
11.01.2016
5/5

jessie if a good bartender always cleaning making sure everything is up to standar especially because of this corona virus, she was super fast with the serving respectful and great conversation! i would love to come out here again

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
IT
Iconic The Group
google
10.22.2016
5/5

Great local spot, attentive service, meatballs we're okay, garlic bread was on 10. Wings were good, pizza really shined, great dough and crust. Please keep your large beers large, best deal I have had in town, was like $5.50 for a 32oz beer!!!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MG
Marlene Gavin
google
09.26.2016
4/5

We went around 4pm on a Sunday. Pizza was good, no disappointments. I thought the place seemed a little dirty. Waitress was very friendly and helpful. This place seemed like more of a hang-out at night for a younger crowd. Live music, meet your friends kind of place. I would go back again.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MK
Machell Kirkpatrick
google
09.10.2016
1/5

Food was good, but discrepancies in the prices on tabs. When asked about it they raised the prices, not a good way to have a returning customer.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
AS
Ashley Sellers
google
08.20.2016
4/5

The regular calzone is massive!! I am scared to see what the extra large looks like. Food was hot. The spaghetti sauce my little wasn't a huge fan of but the serving size is amazing an she was so excited to see the parm cheese. The hubs had the stromboli which was again huge and he was not disappointed. Belly's are full. Thank you!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
LH
Linda Hudson
google
08.14.2016
1/5

I had ordered Tabbouleh and Calzone. The Tabbouleh was a joke and it cost $7.99. Terrible food, the Calzone was dough rolled up with a little cheese and a few pieces of sausage.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
TP
Terry Porter
google
07.16.2016
4/5

Good food lousy music. Dark atmosphere.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
JK
Janice K
google
07.14.2016
2/5

We had a $40.00 Groupon and they wouldn't take it and we spent $48.00 plus tip. The Groupon said it was for four people. They could have still honored it. We were new customers we had never been there before.

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
NB
Nick Bell
google
06.02.2016
1/5

I usually come in a lot and the food is awesome but tonight the portion size was extremely small! I’m very unsatisfied my order usually feeds 4 or 5 people me and my family but tonight the same order only fed me and my wife but we still paid the same as usually so I feel like I got ripped off. Not sure if there is a new cook but whoever it was needs to figure out the right size to make stuff. The flavor was there but it was tiny and undercooked!

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
MC
Marissa Colbert
google
06.02.2016
5/5

Delicious food, great drinks!! Good time

New York Pizza Bar and Grill
TS
Trina Sanchez
google
05.01.2016
5/5

The service was very friendly and great atmosphere. The food was delicious!!! This pecan salad and Calzone was BOMB. The flavor of the bread was really tasty.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12064557155

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!